This is my first crop top - I decided I needed one for the extreme heat this summer (I kept rolling up regular shirts and I'm not comfortable in just a bra), and the design is exactly what I was hoping for. It's very flattering -not too short or compressive - especially with the looser bottom - I'm grateful it's not another band below my bra. I love that it's cute and reversible. It's just the right amount of coverage - an inch or two before my bra, and has never chafed.
My only issue is the fabric - it soaks up all my sweat and gets *heavy*, and takes forever to dry out. I've worn this on several hot long runs and was literally wringing out sweat by mile 7 and just getting worse the longer I go. It reminds me of a soft, less wicking bathing suit top. My roga shorts didn't have this issue on these runs so I'm pretty sure it's just a fabric choice.
I recommend this for people who want to try out a crop top and for short-mid length runs (or people who miraculously don't sweat on hot long runs)
For reference, I'm 5'6", between a b/c, and 145 pounds and the size 4 was great :)